Daily Question Feb 4

Consider the scene of Jacob’s wrestling and answer two simple questions. Who wins, really? And who is his opponent?

In the scene of Jacob’s wrestling, described in Genesis 32, “a man wrestles with [Jacob] until the break of dawn.” Jacob then says “I will not let you go unless you bless me” and Jacob receives this blessing in the form of a name change: “Your name shall no longer be Jacob, for you have striven with beings divine and human, and have prevailed.” This interaction immediately suggests that Jacob’s wrestling opponent is not a mere man, but something more than that, something divine. The exact interpretation of this varies widely, however. The Jewish Study Bible commentary says that “Jacob’s mysterious adversary is surely supernatural, and most traditional Jewish commentators have taken him to be angelic.” The ESV Study Bible, in contrast, suggests that Jacob may have been wrestling directly with God in human form. In the ESV translation, verse 28 reads, “for you have striven with God and with men, and have prevailed,” and in verse 30, Jacob claims “I have seen God face to face, and yet my life has been delivered.” The discrepancy between these two translations and commentaries, while notable, is ultimately not extremely relevant. Whether Jacob’s opponent was the human manifestation of God Himself, or an angelic being, the result remains the same — Jacob had a unique divine encounter, the world’s most bizarre wrestling match to date, which gave way to the blessing he received and his new identity as Israel, which means “He strives with God” or “God strives.” In a strict sense, neither Jacob nor his opponent won the wrestling match, as they were still going and holding on as dawn approached, and then they mutually agreed to stop when Jacob asked for the blessing. The opponent seems to suggest that Jacob “has prevailed” but I don’t think this necessarily means Jacob won, but rather that he had remained determined throughout but ultimately submitted, an apt metaphor for how we should submit to God instead of continuing to wrestle with Him into perpetuity. Finally, the most important thing about this whole scene is the end result and what changed for Jacob. Before the wrestling encounter, he was dreading Esau’s arrival, full of fear and desperation. However, after the divine encounter, he ended the night of struggle with God’s blessing and a renewed faith. This is a clear illustration of the biggest take-away of this story, that though we will inevitably struggle with God in faith, this struggle always leads to peace when we cede to God.

5 thoughts on “Daily Question Feb 4”

  1. In my writing I wrote that I believe a clear winner was determined from this wrestling match and that winner was Jacob because he came out of the encounter with only a bruised hip and a blessing. However I do like the thought of the submission of Jacob in the end to signify the metaphor that we should all submit to God’s rule in the end. I think that in terms of an actual wrestling match, you are correct because n=there was not a winner declared. I also think that Jacob was a winner of that encounter. What do you think?

    Like

  2. I believe how you brought into consideration the Jewish Study Bible and the ESV Study Bible translations and how they vary slightly in wording and thus their interpretation can drastically differ. This brings up an interesting caveat in how we interpret and read the bible as different translation may change the overall meaning of some passages.

    Like

  3. I agree with most of what you say in this piece. However, you say Jacob may not have one, but point out how his mindset about meeting his brother changes after the wrestling match. He becomes confident and at peace with what’s to come. Is this not winning?

    Like

Leave a Reply

Create your own website, free on WordPress.com.Create your own website.
Start free